Instructional design for trainers means rebuilding what a workshop does, not recording what it says. A meta-analysis of 96 research reports found web-based and classroom training about equally effective when both used the same instructional methods. So list what your workshop does (explaining, practice, discussion, feedback), design an online version of each, and keep live time for what needs it.
Key takeaways
- Sitzmann and colleagues' meta-analysis of web-based and classroom instruction found the gap for knowledge was near zero (d = .04) when both used the same instructional methods.
- The same meta-analysis found blended training beat classroom training alone, yet trainees still reacted slightly more favourably to the classroom, and the authors warned against replacing classroom training completely.
- A meta-analysis of 74 distance education studies found that designing interaction into a course improved achievement (g = 0.38), whether between learners, with the instructor or with the content.
- Much of what a workshop does is invisible on the slides: reading the room, adjusting, hearing questions, giving feedback during practice. Each needs a planned replacement online.
- Start with a minute-by-minute inventory of the workshop, tag each block by what it does, and pilot one rebuilt module before converting the rest.
Instructional design for trainers comes down to one shift. In a workshop, you are the course: you explain, set the practice, watch people try it, answer the question nobody wrote down and change direction when the room goes quiet. Online, none of that happens unless it was designed in advance. So turning a workshop into a course isn’t a matter of moving the slides. It’s a matter of moving the methods.
That isn’t just a slogan. The largest comparison of web-based and classroom training, a meta-analysis of 96 research reports covering 19,331 trainees in 168 courses, found that on average web-based instruction was slightly more effective for teaching facts and about equally effective for teaching procedures. When the researchers looked only at studies where both formats used the same instructional methods, the difference all but vanished (Sitzmann et al., 2006).
The guides that rank for this topic mostly offer a conversion checklist: chunk the content, add interactivity, keep videos short. That’s not wrong, but it skips the part trainers find hardest, which is noticing everything the room was doing for them. This guide starts there, then walks through seven steps to rebuild a workshop as an online course, using one example throughout.
What the research says about moving training online
Traci Sitzmann and colleagues pooled studies that compared web-based instruction with classroom instruction on the same content. Their headline results:
- Knowledge of facts and concepts (declarative knowledge): web-based instruction was 6% more effective on average.
- Skills and procedures (procedural knowledge): no meaningful difference (d = -.07).
- Satisfaction: trainees were equally satisfied with both.
- Same methods: when the two formats used the same instructional methods, the knowledge effect was near zero (d = .04). The authors read this as support for the long-standing argument that instructional methods, not delivery media, drive learning.
The authors noticed something else in the reports: the online courses “tended to incorporate more instructional methods” than the classroom ones, and tended to require learners to be more active. In other words, where online training won, it may have won because it asked learners to do more.
The study has limits that matter for trainers. In 67% of the research reports the trainees were undergraduates; employees made up only 15% of courses. And the result depended on the research design. When trainees chose their format, web-based instruction came out ahead (d = .18); when they were randomly assigned, classroom instruction did better (d = -.26). The authors suggest motivated learners may choose online courses when they can, and that onsite instructors may add value the averages hide.
Their most useful finding for a trainer may be the one on blended learning. Web-based instruction combined with classroom sessions was 13% more effective than classroom instruction alone for knowledge and 20% more effective for procedures. Yet trainees reacted 6% more favourably to the classroom on its own. The authors’ advice to organisations follows from that:
A second line of research explains what the classroom contributes. Robert Bernard and colleagues analysed 74 studies of distance education that compared courses with more and less designed interaction. Courses that built in interaction produced higher achievement, with an overall effect of 0.38 (Bernard et al., 2009). In a later summary, the same group reported the effect by type: +0.49 for interaction between students (10 studies), +0.32 for interaction with the instructor (44 studies) and +0.46 for interaction with the content (20 studies) (Abrami et al., 2011).
They also add a warning any trainer who has posted a discussion question will recognise: “just because opportunities for interaction were offered to students does not mean that students availed themselves of them.” Interaction has to be designed so it’s worth doing, not just made available.
What this means in practice: the evidence doesn’t say online training is better or worse than a workshop. It says the outcome depends on what learners do. Rebuild the practice, the discussion and the feedback, and an online course can match the room. Record the talking and drop the rest, and it probably won’t.
What the room was doing for you
Before you convert anything, list the work you do in a workshop that never appears on a slide. Most trainers find it’s a longer list than they expected.
| What happens in the room | Why it matters | What has to replace it online |
|---|---|---|
| You read faces and slow down when people look lost | Pacing matches the group | Short segments, a check question after each, and learner control over pace |
| People ask questions as they think of them | Misconceptions surface early | Questions anticipated in the content, plus a place to ask and a promised response time |
| Learners practise while you watch | You correct errors before they set in | Practice tasks with immediate, specific feedback built into each answer |
| Pairs and tables discuss a case | Learners explain ideas to each other | A discussion prompt with a concrete task and something to produce |
| You tell stories from your own work | Ideas attach to real situations | Your stories recorded or written as cases, placed where they illustrate a point |
| You notice who’s disengaged | You can draw them back in | Progress data, reminders and a reason to come back (a task, a deadline, a cohort) |
This is the inventory the conversion checklists miss. Each row is a teaching method, and each needs a deliberate online replacement, or a decision to keep it live.
Turning a workshop into a course: seven steps
To make each step concrete, we’ll follow one example: a trainer who runs a one-day workshop on handling difficult customer conversations for retail team leaders, and wants a self-paced version for new leaders across several stores. It’s an invented example, but it’s typical of the training that moves online.
1. Decide whether it should be a course at all
Start with analysis: what should people be able to do after the training, and what stops them now? If the answer is “they need to practise a hard conversation with someone watching”, a fully self-paced course may not be the right fix. If they mainly need a framework, examples and practice recognising good and poor responses, most of it can move online. The ADDIE model is a useful frame for this first pass.
For our trainer, the analysis shows new team leaders know the store policies but freeze when a customer escalates. That points to a course built around realistic scenarios, not policy explanation.
2. Write the workshop down, minute by minute
Take your run sheet and list every block of the day with its length. Then tag each block by what it does: tell (you explain), show (you demonstrate), practise (learners do), discuss (learners talk to each other) or feedback (you respond to what they did). Add the unwritten blocks too: the debrief you always run after lunch, the story you tell when someone raises refunds.
Our trainer’s day turns out to be about a third telling, a third role-play and a third discussion and debrief. The slides cover only the first third. The role-play and the discussion carry most of the learning, so they warrant most of the design effort when the workshop becomes a course.
Asynchronous discussion forums can take on part of that work, but not all of it. In our own conversions, a substantial share of the design time goes into short video prompts that frame each discussion, and into recorded explanations that capture the nuance a live debrief would surface and direct learners’ attention to what matters most. No online format fully reproduces the collaborative energy of a room in mid-discussion. Acknowledging that limitation, and distributing the work across several modes rather than relying on any one, is what makes the conversion workable.
3. Rewrite the objectives as things learners do
Workshop objectives are often written loosely because the trainer can adjust on the day. A self-paced course can’t, so each objective needs to describe something learners will do that you could check. “Understand de-escalation” becomes “choose the response that acknowledges the customer’s concern before explaining the policy, in a set of realistic scenarios”. Our guide on how to write learning objectives covers the method, and backward design explains why the assessment comes next, before any content.
4. Keep each method, change the vehicle
Go through your tagged inventory and choose an online version of each block:
- Tell becomes short videos or text, each ending with a question that makes learners use the idea. Our guide to course video length covers how long to make them.
- Show becomes a worked example: a recorded demonstration, or a transcript of a good conversation with your commentary on why each move works.
- Practise becomes scenario questions with feedback on every option, so a wrong answer explains what would happen and why. This is retrieval practice plus feedback that improves performance.
- Discuss becomes a structured task (step 5).
- Feedback on complex work becomes a submitted task that you or a peer reviews against a short checklist.
For our trainer, the morning role-plays become branching scenarios: learners read a customer’s complaint, choose a response, and see how the customer reacts and why. The method, practice with feedback, survives. Only the vehicle changes.
5. Design the interaction on purpose
Bernard and colleagues’ results suggest all three kinds of interaction help, but Abrami and colleagues’ warning applies: offering a discussion board isn’t the same as getting people to use it. Give each interaction a reason to exist.
- With other learners: instead of “share your thoughts”, ask each person to post how they’d open a specific difficult conversation, then reply to one other post with a suggested improvement.
- With you: schedule feedback on a submitted piece of work, such as a short recorded or written response to a scenario, and say when learners will hear back.
- With the content: practice questions, worked examples and a short task at the end of every segment.
6. Decide what stays live
The blended result in Sitzmann and colleagues’ meta-analysis is a strong argument for not converting everything. Keep live time for the blocks where learners need to perform in front of someone, or where discussion does the teaching.
Our trainer keeps one 60-minute live online session per cohort for role-plays in pairs, after learners have finished the self-paced scenarios. The explaining and first practice happen online, at each learner’s pace; the live hour is spent entirely on practice and feedback, which is the part of the workshop that mattered most.
7. Pilot one module before converting the rest
Build one complete module, with its practice and feedback, and put it in front of four or five real learners before you build anything else. Watch where they stall, which feedback they skip and which questions they get wrong for the wrong reasons. Our guide on how to pilot a course before launch walks through it.
Five mistakes trainers make when they go online
- Recording the workshop and calling it a course. A recording keeps the telling and drops the practice, discussion and feedback, which is usually where the learning happened.
- Keeping lecture-length segments. In the room you broke up a long explanation with questions and activities without thinking about it. Online, build those breaks in.
- Testing recall when the job needs judgement. If the workshop practised decisions, the course should too. A scenario question tests more than a definition.
- Posting discussion questions with no task. Learners skip optional discussion. Give them something specific to produce and someone to respond to.
- Leaving your stories behind. The examples you tell from experience often carry the workshop. Write them down and place them where they illustrate a point.
What to do next
Take the run sheet for your most-requested workshop and tag every block as tell, show, practise, discuss or feedback, including the blocks that aren’t written down. That one page shows you what the course has to replace, and which parts deserve to stay live.
Reader poll
Two quick questions about how you work.
Answer to see the results
Bars show how readers of this page answered. Answers are anonymous. It is a reader poll, not a representative survey.
Questions people ask
What is instructional design for trainers?
It's the planning work behind a course, applied to training you currently deliver in person: working out what learners must be able to do, how they'll practise it, how they'll get feedback and how you'll know it worked. For a trainer, the main shift is that a self-paced course can't rely on you in the room, so everything you do live has to be designed in advance.
Is eLearning as effective as classroom training?
On average, roughly. Sitzmann and colleagues' 2006 meta-analysis found web-based instruction slightly more effective for factual knowledge and about equal for procedural skills, with similar satisfaction. The gap disappeared when both used the same instructional methods. But most studies involved university students, and in randomised studies the classroom did better, so the delivery format matters less than what the course asks learners to do.
Can I just record my workshop and put it online?
You can, but a recording keeps the explaining and loses the rest: the practice, the discussion and the feedback you gave as people worked. Those are usually what made the workshop effective. A recording can be useful raw material, cut into short segments, but each segment then needs practice and feedback designed around it.
What's the difference between a trainer and an instructional designer?
A trainer delivers learning, usually live, and adjusts in the moment. An instructional designer plans learning so it works without that adjustment: objectives, practice, assessment, sequence and materials. Many trainers already do design work informally when they build a workshop. Moving training online makes that work explicit, because the course has to do what you used to do in the room.
Should I convert all of my classroom training to eLearning?
Probably not all of it. In Sitzmann and colleagues' meta-analysis, blended training (web-based instruction plus classroom sessions) outperformed classroom training alone, and the authors cautioned against replacing classroom training entirely. Move the explaining and individual practice online, and keep live time for role-plays, discussion and anything where learners need you to watch them perform.
Sources
- Sitzmann, T., Kraiger, K., Stewart, D., & Wisher, R. (2006). The comparative effectiveness of web-based and classroom instruction: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 59(3), 623–664. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.2006.00049.x
- Bernard, R. M., Abrami, P. C., et al. (2009). A meta-analysis of three types of interaction treatments in distance education. Review of Educational Research, 79(3), 1243–1289. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654309333844
- Abrami, P. C., Bernard, R. M., Bures, E. M., Borokhovski, E., & Tamim, R. M. (2011). Interaction in distance education and online learning: Using evidence and theory to improve practice. Journal of Computing in Higher Education, 23, 82–103. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12528-011-9043-x
The month in learning design
New research on the future of learning, what it means for your course, and a spotlight on subscribers we select at random to feature their products, courses and discoveries. Free, once a month.